Old Fashioned Beef Stew

Old Fashioned Beef Stew

When I was looking for a recipe for the simple stew I grew up with, a friend came through for me, the same friend who passed on what has become our family’s favorite Thanksgiving stuffing. Here’s the recipe for the easiest stew, ever, Old Fashioned Beef Stew. You might see this same stew sometimes called Five Hour Stew and you’ll see why soon enough!

Old Fashioned Beef Stew

Old Fashioned Beef Stew


I knew right away that this was exactly the stew I was looking for because it has one key component in it. Tapioca is used to thicken the stew and it adds a beautiful gorgeous shine. I did vary the recipe just a bit over time but not by much!

About Old Fashioned Beef Stew:

This really is an old fashioned stew. The kind of stew a family would make to stretch a little beef and get dinner on the table back in the day. It’s the kind of simple, plain down-home cooking I just about crave sometimes! There’s no doubt I do a lot of cooking and am always about finding flavors to tantalize the taste buds, but hey, sometimes you just have to come home and if you can’t do that in person, you just might be able to do it at the dinner table.

What you’re going to find in this stew is beef, salt and pepper and an array of veggies, standard stew veggies, and a good proportion of them. There are the potatoes (which I always think of as the star of the show), onions, carrots, and celery, peas if ya want (I never do!) canned tomatoes, a little salt, and pepper and a touch of sugar. Trust me on that one!. And of course the tapioca.

What you’re not going to find is any wine, bacon, garlic, spices or herbs, Worcestershire sauce, pearl onions, mushrooms or anything “fancy” at all. As much as I love some of the other stews I make (check this Beef Stew with Wine or Not) it’s kind of amazing how good just the taste of food can be, standing on its own.

I can still remember Mom standing me on a chair next to the sink, showing me how to peel the carrots and potatoes for this recipe. I got the peeler, she just used what today we’d probably call a paring knife. Honestly, back then I don’t think she even had so much as a Chef knife or anything that would pass as one! And her little knife was used for everything, and almost everything was held in her hand as she cut (no cutting board) and dropped it right in the pot, with the exception of the beef, which was sliced right on the butcher’s paper.

Old Fashioned Beef Stew

Old Fashioned Beef Stew

About Tapioca:

I don’t think tapioca is as popular in the States it was in the past (unless you’re making bubble tea which is a different type.) So just to clarify, the tapioca that you’ll typically find in an American supermarket comes in a little red & white cardboard box, or at least the only brand I know of does, and you’ll find it right by the jello and puddings. You’ll find standard tapioca which takes longer to cook and Instant tapioca, which is used in this recipe.

And while tapioca is used as a thickener as in this stew, in pies & cobblers & other desserts and sometimes other items as a gluten-free (depending on the tapioca) alternative, it’s also used in tapioca pudding. As a matter of fact, homemade tapioca pudding is pretty amazing, especially if you’ve only had it in the little pudding cups or at a cafeteria before. Maybe it’s time to post a recipe for that, too. It’s surprising how little tapioca is needed for a recipe, but it does keep just about forever in a dark, cool cupboard.



Making Old Fashioned Beef Stew:

When I say this is a simple stew, I really mean it. All the ingredients are added to the pot and the pot is closed and percolates away, low and slow in the oven until finished, five hours at a low heat. Don’t lift the lid or peak, or at least not until close to the end, and only if you want to check the liquid level, which might be a good idea the first time you make this if your oven isn’t accurate.

There is no browning of the meat (which can be a cut from the round or chuck; I prefer chuck), no sauteing of the vegetables. I suppose you could if you wish, but it kind of goes against the simple, stewed flavor of the recipe. The only thing to keep in mind is that while you don’t have to have perfect cuts, you’ll need to pay a little attention to the size of the veggies so everything is done when the beef has reached that beautiful tender stage.

This stew can be made in the slow cooker, too. I’m not that comfortable leaving my house with the oven on, so I only cook this stew in the oven when I know I’ll be around for the full five hours. The slow cooker does a fabulous job, too, and I feel safe with it bubbling away on my counter. I add a little less water and more time when this is in the slow cooker.

Old Fashioned Beef Stew

Old Fashioned Beef Stew

Saving Money on Old Fashioned Beef Stew:

Much as I love Pot Roasts and Stews, I gotta admit some of the old-school country type meat & potato meals don’t always give the best “bang for your buck.” In this case, a more modest amount of meat is stretched with a lot of veggies, which is always a great strategy for keeping in budget. Do shop well for your more inexpensive roasts like chuck or cuts from the round, stocking your freezer when they’re at a low.

Generally, you’ll find the best pricing in the fall as well as a week or two after any Holiday in which more pricy beef cuts are served. That’s usually going to be January and February. After the Christmas roasts and the New Year’s and Valentine’s day steaks are over, something has to be done with the remainder of the beef.

Stretch this meal further, serving with rolls or maybe with grits or over polenta, and squirrel away any leftovers to come back later, maybe as a pie or Shepherd’s pie. It will seem like “more” served in a pie form! Check out my post on Steak Pie, Beef & Guinness Pie or Shepherd’s Pie from Leftover Pot Roast for the methods and timing and just sub your leftover stew in.

Basic veggies like this are generally cheap, most less than a dollar a pound. All are going to be less $ per pound in the larger bags. Keep onions and potatoes separate and store in a dark, cool place. A closed paper bag works well; don’t keep them in plastic if you’ve bought them that way. Carrots go in the fridge, but make sure the bag is ventilated and not sitting in the ridges of your veggie drawer. Turn them around now and then and they’ll stay fresher longer. Simply close the plastic bag over your celery (clip it, staple it, tape it) and it will stay fresher longer.

Shop well for your pantry staples and get in the habit of picking items that you use often like canned tomatoes up at a low whether you need them or not if you aren’t fully stocked; usually, they’ll hit rock bottom pricing once a quarter. You don’t ever want to run out of your basic pantry items and have to pay more.


Old Fashioned Beef Stew

Old Fashioned Beef Stew


Old Fashioned Beef Stew

  • Total Time: 5 1/2 hours to 8 1/2 hours
  • Yield: 8 servings 1x
  • Category: Main Dish Meat
  • Cuisine: American


  • 2 pounds round or chuck, 1 1/4′ cubes
  • 1 onion, diced
  • 5 to 6 potatoes, peeled and cut into 1 1/2 to 1 3/4″ chunks
  • 3 medium-sized carrots, peeled, in about 1” chunks, thick ends sliced in half the long way first
  • 1 to 2 stalks celery, cut crosswise into 3/8″ slices (about a cup)
  • 1 cup frozen peas, optional
  • 28 ounce can of crushed tomatoes
  • 1 to 2 cups water
  • 3 tablespoons instant tapioca
  • 1 tablespoon sugar
  • 2 teaspoons salt
  • 1/2 teaspoon pepper


Oven Option:

Preheat oven to 250 degrees F.

Place all ingredients, using 2 cups water, in a Dutch oven with a tight fitting lid. Stir together. For easier cleanup, wipe down any residue from stirring that is above the level of the food. Cover and bake without lifting lid for five hours.

Slow Cooker Option:

Place all ingredients slow cooker, using one cup of water. Mix, cover and cook on low for 8 hours or high for 5 until meat is tender.

For Both Options:

Taste before serving and adjust seasoning to taste. If stew seems too thick, feel free to add a little water.

Keywords: Beef, Carrots, celery, Chuck Roast, Family Recipe, Peas, Potatoes, Round Steak, Slow Cooker, Stew

Did you make this recipe?

Share a photo and tag us — we can't wait to see what you've made!


I’ll be sharing at Fiesta Friday #314 hosted this week by Liz @ Spades, Spatulas & Spoons and the at the Weekend Potluck #414 at South Your Mouth. Be sure to stop by if you’d like to catch up on your favorite bloggers in one place every week.

This is a truly Old Fashioned Beef Stew, sometimes called Five Hour Stew. It's low and slow old fashioned cooking. It's like coming home! Simple flavors, no effort to make! #ClassicBeefStew #OldFashionedBeefStew #FiveHourStew #SimpleBeefStew #BeefStew

26 thoughts on “Old Fashioned Beef Stew

    • FrugalHausfrau

      Hi Kate. It would be a great gluten free option for stew with the tapioca if you can find a brand that it gluten free! 🙂

  1. ok…….I wasn’t done yet and hit the botton! 🙂 the stew looks amazing and this would be perfect to make with the cold weather we have been receiving recently. i have never heard of putting tapioca in stew, but i am guessing it thickens it a little which would be amazing.

  2. That’s a beautiful looking stew!
    Tapioca used to be a popular pudding in the UK, but I’ve since discovered that it’s used for all sorts of dishes in Brazil. It makes a very tasty elastic dough which they stuff with all sorts of sweet and savoury fillings. It’s also used for starching clothes.

  3. Ron

    What a wonderful-looking stew and one that brings back memories of my childhood school days. I loved my school cafeteria’s beef stew, but then the only stew I got at home came from a can that said, Denny Moore. Your old fashion beef stew reminds me of theirs as it always had a glisten to it. I bet they used tapioca in it. I’ve not used tapioca in beef stew, used it elsewhere but not beef stew. I love the slow and low oven option.

    • FrugalHausfrau

      Hi Ron, I have a friend who loves that canned stew. Hey, we all have some deep dark secret and I suppose there are worse ones! So one night we had a little dinner party with that stew as the featured entree! I grew up around dogs (I usually say I was raised by them, lol) and when that can popped open i couldn’t help but be taken aback and draw a few comparisons between the stew and the cans my Dad insisted on feeding our pups back in the day.

      Surprisingly, the taste was better than I expected! but we def should have had more wine, lol!!

  4. 250F? Is that a type-o? I’m a-scared of that temperature. LOL

    Mmmm this sounds delicious though! And the peas are A MUST for me. I remember I made beef stew for a neighbor once and accidentally put WAY too many peas in it. When I asked if Neighbor wanted seconds he said “No…I’m about pea’d out.” Hahahahaha.

    VERY interesting about the tapioca!! I didn’t know it was used for thickening things. I only know it from the super yummy tapioca pudding I always get at Tallyrand Restaurant in Burbank, CA. So vanilla-y and creamy. So YES, please do post a recipe for that pudding if you have one for us.

    Oh and my mom always held veggies in her hand and cut them with a paring knife, too. I don’t think I would have the nerve. LOL

    Thanks for this stew recipe. I shall try it!

    • FrugalHausfrau

      I actually did just correct a couple of typos (long day!) but the 250 wasn’t one of them!! I suppose it’s kind of like when you cook bbq low and slow. So funny and I agree with your neighbor! If there are peas in something I usually eat them first so I can get the taste out of my mouth with the rest of dinner, lol!! Although i do like them in some things!! I will google that tapioca!! I love it. I have little space (my sister, too) between my front teeth at the top and when I was a kid I loved to squirt the tapioca through, haha!

      This recipe if you want, can be zipped up a little with some onion or garlic salt, a little Worcestershire sauce, not much, just a little. I bet your Mom probably made this stew. It was kind of the standard for ages back in the 50’s and 6o’s!

Hearing from you makes my day! Comment below.

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.