Doctoring Canned Baked Beans

Doctoring Canned Baked Beans

Do you have your top secret Ninja ways to make plain old canned baked beans taste more like homemade? I have a couple of tricks up my sleeve, depending on what kind of beans I want. Most of the time when I’m Doctoring Canned Baked Beans, I’m looking for kind of delish New England style, a bit zippy, a little sweet and super flavorful and that’s what these are.

Doctoring Canned Baked Beans

Doctoring Canned Baked Beans


Not that there’s anything wrong about heating up a can of baked beans for a quick side, but I guess I just like to put my own spin on things and add a little extra goodness – without going through the heroics of cooking my own from scratch.

About Doctoring Canned Baked Beans:

First of all, if I’m just looking for a quick weeknight side for burgers or something simple, I just drain off the excess liquid that floats on top of the beans when the can is first opened, then toss the beans in a pan and add a squirt of ketchup, a touch of regular old ballpark mustard, a bit of brown sugar and heat them slowly for a few minutes until hot and bubbly and everything has dissolved into a thick sauce. Done. And what a difference that two minutes of effort makes. Boom. Mike drop.

But when I have a little time on my hands and want my canned beans to taste like real home-style cooked for hours from scratch, I take it a few steps further. In goes bacon and onion to cook until tender, then beans with some sweet brown sugar and deep, earthy molasses. A touch of ketchup adds a rich tomatoey vinegary goodness. Then that’s all fortified with the faintest touch of vinegar and lots of mustard powder to give some tang to offset the sweet.  That’s my “secret” ingredient right there, the mustard powder. If I’m really feeling it, I might add a whisper of ground ginger; it gives a little zip, but that just depends on my mood.

Then I bake those beans in a casserole, in the oven, slowly, for a good hour, until the top has darkened and almost caramelized, the beans are bubbling and thoroughly hot throughout and the smell is just about driving everyone cray cray. And about the time someone asks, “Aren’t those beans done yet?” They are. That’s when I pull those glorious molten beans from the oven and scoop through the top layer, the steam pouring out, and I reach with the spoon, straight down to reveal those saucier beans below. And every serving has a combination of the sticky sweet caramelized beans from the top and the saucier ones from below and you know there’s bacon! They’re glorious. I think I’m going to go have some right now before I even finish this post or edit the photos. I’ve been tantalized by that aroma for far too long. Excuse me a minute….I’ll be back!

Doctoring Canned Baked Beans

Doctoring Canned Baked Beans

Making Doctoring Canned Baked Beans:

My favorite beans to use for this recipe are Bush’s Baked Beans, the original flavor but this still works well with their Original, Brown Sugar, Onion and Homestyle beans. They have about 14 varieties now and I haven’t tried them all. I wouldn’t use any of their “Grillin’ Beans” for this recipe.

I gotta tell ya, I think the recipe/method is the best, but it does take quite a while in the oven. If you want to shortcut it a bit, when you first open up the can, just like I described if you’re making beans in the saucepan, drain a some of the liquid off. Then proceed with the recipe, but only bake it for a half an hour or so or just until bubbly.

When I make my beans, I always chop up the bacon and cook it with the onions; another variation is to just lay the bacon over the top of the casserole and bake it at 400 degrees until the beans are bubbly and the bacon is crisped through. That’s never been my fave way because it’s hard to get the bacon just right but a lot of people love their beans that way and it looks impressive when it comes to the table.

Saving Money on Doctoring Canned Baked Beans:

Canned beans really do scream summer and barbecues and cookouts. Watch or them on sale sporadically through the summer and especially before every holiday. The price can get surprising low. Stock up at the low; it never hurts to have a can or two on hand to fill out a meal and once you try this recipe, you might be wanting to make them more often.

Bacon is one item I really shop strategically for. It’s generally on sale before every holiday, often at half price. Since it doesn’t take up much room in the freezer, it makes sense to stock up on bacon, too.

I’ve pretty much always baked and always have a little molasses on hand. It keeps for years, just be sure the cap and lip of the bottle are clean before storing back in the pantry or you’ll never get it open again. A little molasses, along with white sugar, make “brown sugar” so it’s handy to have some molasses in the pantry if you don’t regularly use brown sugar. If your brown sugar has hardened, either add a piece of bread to the bag and let sit overnight or place in the microwave, cover with a damp paper towel and microwave in 30-second intervals.

Doctoring Canned Baked Beans

Doctoring Canned Baked Beans

Doctoring Canned Baked Beans

  • Servings: 8
  • Difficulty: easy
  • Print

Shortcut this recipe by draining off the excess liquid from the top of the can and baking for 30 minutes.

  • 2 (28 ounce) cans Bush’s Baked Beans, original recipe preferred
  • five to six slices of bacon, diced
  • 1 small onion, diced finely
  • 2 tablespoons water
  • 1/4 to 1/3 cup brown sugar
  • 1/4 cup ketchup
  • 1 1/2 tablespoons mustard powder (or to taste)
  • 1 tablespoon molasses
  • 1 teaspoon white or apple cider vinegar
  • 1/4 teaspoon ground ginger, optional

_Preheat oven to 350 degrees F. Have a two-quart casserole at the ready.

In a large pot or Dutch oven, add the bacon, onion, and water. Cook, stirring often until bacon is rendered (but not crisp) and onion nearly tender, and all water evaporated. Add in beans, brown sugar to taste, ketchup, mustard powder, molasses, and apple cider vinegar. Stir and bring to a boil. Add ginger, if desired.

Place beans in casserole, place in oven and bake about 1 hour, uncovered until top has darkened but isn’t burned, watch it at the end, and beans are bubbling and piping hot. Remove and let sit for several minutes before serving.


  • If you don’t have brown sugar on hand, just add white sugar and a 1/2 teaspoon more molasses.
  • Beans will thicken as they cool and become quite thick if refrigerated. Reheat with a little water, if desired.


I’ll be sharing Doctoring Canned Baked Beans at Fiesta Friday #280. The hosts this week are Angie of Fiesta Friday and  Ai @ Ai Made It For You.

This method of Doctoring Canned Baked Beans is going to have you swearing these are cooked for hours, from scratch home-cooked Baked Beans! #DoctoringCannedBeans #HomemadeBeansFromCanned #FixingCannedBeans #BestBakedBeans


11 thoughts on “Doctoring Canned Baked Beans

  1. Pingback: Doctoring Canned Baked Beans — Frugal Hausfrau | My Meals are on Wheels

  2. Ron

    Is there any other way to make baked beans? A very solid recipe Mollie and a method I’ve used for years except I just yellow mustard instead of powder. But, alas, we have no Bush’s baked beans here so I have to go all in and make from scratch. Maybe I’ll try making them with Heinz beans in tomato sauce.

    • FrugalHausfrau

      Thanks, Ron. I saw a thread from someone in Great Britian that said they only have Heinz, too. Must be about time for Bush’s to go international! I love these beans – they taste like “Home” to me!

  3. Vanessa

    Lots of inspiration in this post. I am not a fan of regular canned baked beans because I find them way too sweet. However I love your ideas about doctoring up canned anything else. One of the things that I like to do is get a can of can of cannellini beans and cook it in some garlic and olive oil and bacon and onion and then add a can of drained tuna and cook that together, and top it with a fried egg. I realize that might sound weird but I promise you it is delicious. And cheap so I know you would like it!

    • FrugalHausfrau

      Actually, it sounds weirdly good!! I am going to have to check it out! I love to take a can of cannellini beans with the juices and put it in a pan with about 1/2 cup of cream. When it’s done, squeeze in half a lemon. It makes the most amazing side dish!

  4. I add a tablespoon or two of brown sugar, a slug of balsamic vinegar and a shake of smoked paprika. If I’m feeling really fancy some smoked speck and mushrooms and onion are fried and added at the last minute!

    • FrugalHausfrau

      Oh my gosh, that sounds heavenly!! Much more upscale than mine but now I know how I am making them next time!!

Hearing from you makes my day! Comment below.

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.