Spider Cake

Spider Cake

New England Spider Cake. Have you had it? If not, you’ve been missing out on not just the dish but an experience. This is one of those old-fashioned heritage dishes that translate very well to today’s cooking methods and tastes. In other words, it’s not just something you have to have grown up with in order to love.

Spider Cake

Spider Cake – just look at that custardy goodness!


 

Although, I guarantee that Spider Cake is probably like nothing you’ve ever had. Some might liken it to cornbread and it shares some of the same qualities. But it’s not cornbread. Nope, nope, nope, Spider Cake is special.

About New England Spider Cake:

I cannot rave enough about Spider Cake – it’s a kind of moist, almost spoon bread type of cornbread but it’s the perfect combination of savory and sweet. And it’s baked in a cast-iron skillet. When you cut into it, there are layers of soft custard-like cake in between the slightly crispy layers of the cornmeal. If you’ve had any of the seminola, polenta or cornmeal cakes that have become more popular recently you’ll have an idea of what the Spider cake tastes like. But then, that custard!! Oh, my! That’s what keeps you going back for more. This is one of those “just another bite” type of dishes.

Serve it for breakfast with berries, powdered sugar or syrup. Serve it for dessert – maybe later in the evening after a light dinner. Even though it is a little sweet, I’ll sometimes serve it with chilis and soups and pulled pork and ribs and anywhere you would normally serve cornbread. Speaking of cornbread, here’s my menu of Cornbread Recipes if you’d like to take a peek.

Why is this called Spider Cake?  No, it’s not a Paleo diet thing! Back in the day before ovens were available, this cake was cooked in a hearth over coals in a cast iron pan nicknamed a spider – the pan had multiple legs on the bottom to keep it off the coals, something like the outdoor Dutch Ovens we have today, only taller. And of course, spiders have legs. I originally found the recipe in one of the “Best American Recipe” Cookbooks by Molly StevensFran McCullough.

Spider Cake

Spider Cake

Making Spider Cake:

Spider Cake is super simple to make. You’ll notice the recipe calls for 2 cups of whole milk mixed with vinegar. Use buttermilk if you have it, but since the cake is so simple the extra richness from the whole milk helps. And of course, the cup of cream doesn’t hurt at all!

I almost always make this in a 12-inch skillet. The cake’s a little flatter, but the layers, to me, seem a little more distinct. Today, when I did the photos in the red skillet, I used a 10″ and as you can see, the custardy layer is more toward the top. No one is paying me to say this, but I love my little red Lodge enameled cast iron skillet. It was a fraction of the cost of the more expensive ones out there, and I count on anything from Lodge to last a lifetime and probably be passed down, too.

Whatever you do, make sure to “rest” the batter for a few minutes so that it thickens up just a bit as the cornmeal absorbs the moisture. That extra bit of thickness helps the cream spread properly to form that distinct, custardy layer.

Spider Cake

Spider Cake

Saving Money on Spider Cake:

Eggs are often on sale during almost any Holiday that normally includes baking. Look specials giving discounts or free eggs when you buy other items like bacon or sausage.  Stock up when they’re inexpensive because they last for weeks in the fridge. The date on the container is a ‘buy’ date, and you can expect them to last a good six weeks to two months at home past that date. Never store your eggs in the door; they keep best in a colder part of the refrigerator, in their own box.

I ALWAYS look for specials on Cream. it will last several weeks in the fridge (because of the high-fat content) if not opened. It is generally a sale on whipping cream (watch for those sales just before a holiday comes up) that prompts me to pull out the few favorite recipes I like to use it in, not the other way around. There are HUGE price variances between on sale and regular pricing. Aldi, too, has great prices.

The rest of the baking goods I generally pick up during the fall/winter holidays and/or Easter when almost all baking goods are on sale. Aldi, again, had great prices; they often beat out my grocery store sale prices. Speaking of Easter, that is the best time of year to pick up sales priced vinegar. Look for the basic jugs and watch for the fancier vinegar to be on sale, too.

Spider Cake

Spider Cake

Print

Spider Cake

Spider Cake
  • Author: Best American Recipes
  • Total Time: 50 minutes
  • Yield: 6 to 8 small 1x
  • Category: Breakfast or Brunch
  • Cuisine: American
Scale

Ingredients

  • 2 cups whole milk
  • 4 teaspoons white vinegar
  • 1 cup all-purpose flour
  • 3/4 cup yellow cornmeal
  • 3/4 cup sugar
  • 1/2 teaspoon baking soda
  • 1/2 teaspoon salt
  • 2 eggs
  • 2 tablespoons butter
  • 1 cup heavy cream, but milk works, too; I’ve even seen old recipes made with water.

Instructions

Preheat oven to 350 degrees.

Combine milk and vinegar in a bowl and set aside to sour.

In another bowl, combine flour, cornmeal, sugar, baking soda, and salt. Whisk eggs into the soured milk. Stir the wet into dry ingredients and set batter aside for several minutes.  If you skip the rest, you won’t get dramatic of rivulets of cream in the finished product.

Put butter in a 12-inch cast-iron skillet and put in the oven to melt.  Remove skillet from oven, tilting so the butter coats the sides. Pour in the batter. Very carefully and slowly, pour cream into the center of the batter. Slide skillet into the oven and bake until golden brown on top, about 40 – 45 minutes. Do not overbake!

There will be strange cracks emanating from the center of the cake, and it is done when the edges of the cake pull away from the pan. Slice into wedges and serve warm.

Note: When pouring the cream, the Spider Cake will work out much better if you use a spouted measuring cup so you have a little more control.

 

Super easy and super delish, this old-fashioned Spider Cake is like a cornbread cousin. It's a cross between cornbread and cake. Cream poured in the center before baking turns into a layer of custard running through the cake! #SpiderCake #Cornbread #NewEnglandSpiderCake

6 thoughts on “Spider Cake

  1. FrugalHausfrau

    What a treasure those old cookbooks are!! I have one of my grandma’s and I love seeing the little pencil marks here and there and little smudges and spatters are a sure sign it was a fave recipe!

  2. smokeytoes

    I grew up eating this cake, with fresh milk from the dairy down the street. Nothing brings back pleasant memories of home like having a slice of this heavenly delight.

    • FrugalHausfrau

      I can only imagine how good that was! I grew up with a dairy down the street, too, and remember touring it as one of our kindergarten field trips! #MissTheOldDays!!

      Mollie

      • smokeytoes

        Since the shelter in place began, I’ve been making a lot of recipes I grew up on, like 7-layer salad and this cake (drizzled with maple syrup). My husband is glad I saved my grandmother’s old cookbook…

Hearing from you makes my day! Comment below.

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.