On my site already is a recipe for Scalloped Potatoes Like Your Grandma Made. I love those, and they are def a go-to at my house, especially after any holiday with ham (when I often sprinkle in both cheese and ham between the layers). However, if you examine that post and delve into the comments and discussion, you’ll see that many asked for the recipe for these Old-Fashioned Scalloped Potatoes – they strike a huge nostalgic note.